Hospital Threatens to Take Little Girl Off Life Support, But Mom Wants Specialist to Treat Her

State   |   Texas Right to Life   |   Jul 16, 2020   |   9:36AM   |   Houston, Texas

A doctor agreed to perform a tracheostomy for Baby Tinslee Lewis, the 17-month old at the center of a legal dispute regarding Texas’ 10-Day Rule. The family’s lawyers filed a motion on Tuesday afternoon in a Tarrant County district court asking the court to require Cook Children’s Medical Center to grant emergency privileges to Dr. Glenn E. Green. After reviewing her medical records, Dr. Green concluded that her episodes of severe desaturation – what Cook’s has described as “dying spells” – may be attributable to underlying airway issues which are often treatable.

Dr. Green, a professor of otolaryngology at the University of Michigan, would evaluate Baby Tinslee for airway malacia and perform a tracheostomy. Dr. Patrick Roughneen, a physician from Galveston, Texas, assessed Baby Tinslee in person, concurred with Dr. Green, and disagreed with the medical diagnosis of the doctors at Cook Children’s Medical Center. In a declaration filed in the 48th Judicial District in Tarrant County, Dr. Roughneen stated that he saw “no evidence” of pulmonary hypertension.

Texas Right to Life, Protect TX Fragile Kids, and the Lewis family have worked tirelessly to fight for Baby Tinslee. As part of their efforts to help her, they asked Dr. Green to review Baby Tinslee’s medical records. There are no doctors in Dr. Green’s specialty and subspecialty at Cook Children’s Medical Center. Accordingly, Trinity Lewis, Baby Tinslee’s mother, asked Cook’s to allow Dr. Green to evaluate Baby Tinslee and provide her with medical care.

Click here to sign up for pro-life news alerts from

The motion filed Tuesday asks the court to require Cook’s to allow Dr. Green to care for Baby Tinslee. Both doctors filed declarations with the court stating that the tracheostomy request was medically appropriate.

Dr. Roughneen said:

Baby T.L. should be treated no differently than any other child who has been on a ventilator this long. Tracheotomies are routinely performed for patients after 14-days on a ventilator. Baby T.L. has been on a ventilator for over 10 months. It is not within the standard realm of care to leave a patient on a ventilator this long and refuse a tracheostomy. The benefits of a tracheostomy versus a ventilator are decreased work of breathing, reduction in airway dead space, avoidance of tracheo-innominate fistula [a lethal complication of an indwelling tracheostomy tube] and management of pulmonary secretions. Hence there are very specific patient benefits to performing this procedure.