California Student Wins Free Speech Case Over Schools Denial of Pro-Life Shirt

State   |   Steven Ertelt   |   Jan 1, 2009   |   9:00AM   |   WASHINGTON, DC

California Student Wins Free Speech Case Over School’s Denial of Pro-Life Shirt

by Steven Ertelt Editor
August 13
, 2010

Fresno, CA ( — In a victory for pro-life speech in public schools, a federal court entered a judgment Thursday against a California elementary school and three school officials. The court determined they violated the First, Fourth, and Fourteenth Amendment rights of a 6th grade student who wore a pro-life T-shirt.

School officials barred Tiffany Amador from wearing her pro-life T-shirt at McSwain Union Elementary School, a kindergarten through 8th grade school located in Merced, north of Fresno.

On April 29, 2008, Amador wore a shirt sponsored by American Life League, which sponsors the annual National Pro-Life T-shirt Week.

The shirt, given to the young girl by her church, prominently featured the word “ABORTION” over a series of panels, two of which depicted endoscopic pictures of a baby developing in the womb and the third filled in with black. The caption read, “growing…growing…gone.”

Amador testified in the case that she wore the shirt to school because she wanted other students to known that “abortion is wrong.”

The school claimed the images of the baby were “disruptive” to the school environment because of their “graphic nature” but could not explain what made them so graphic that they would have caused any disruption

Los Angeles attorney William J. Becker, with help from the Thomas More Law Center, filed suit.

He said the school was unable to prove how the pro-life shirt would create a "substantial" disruption, as the U.S. Supreme Court has held is required before a school can infringe upon a student’s expressive rights.

“This judgment represents a victory for the right to speak out against abortion,” Becker told today. “Public school students are not forbidden from proclaiming the value of life under the First Amendment."

"The school has done the right thing by avoiding a trial and allowing a judgment to be entered in favor of this student on all claims," Becker continued. "All Americans, no matter their age, are free to exercise their constitutional right to speak out against the barbarism of on-demand abortion, and that includes public school students who do so in a non-disruptive manner.”

In addition to claiming that her First Amendment right of expression was violated, Amador, who has since graduated from the 8th grade, alleged in the lawsuit that her Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable search and seizure was violated when the school’s secretary forcefully pulled her into the principal’s office because of her pro-life shirt.

“Public school employees work for the government,” Becker said. “Any time a school official uses physical force to suppress non-disruptive student expression, the government has gone way too far in enforcing its own political views.”

The lawsuit also sought vindication of Amador’s 14th Amendment right of equal protection. The judgment was entered on all claims, Becker explained.

“Student speech at all grade levels is protected by the First Amendment,” Becker said. “With few exceptions, such as profanity and lewdness, the Constitution prohibits school officials from picking and choosing what messages they find acceptable and what messages they find unacceptable."

"The message of the shirt was that life demands respect. This is a particularly vital message for vulnerable young girls. The pictures conveyed a message that could not be misunderstood, and that frightened school authorities, who are left without meaningful guidance as to what students can and cannot say. Perhaps they will be less prone to trampling a student’s rights," Becker concluded.


Sign Up for Free Pro-Life News From

Daily Pro-Life News Report Twice-Weekly Pro-Life
News Report
Receive a free daily email report from with the latest pro-life news stories on abortion, euthanasia and stem cell research. Sign up here. Receive a free twice-weekly email report with the latest pro-life news headlines on abortion, euthanasia and stem cell research. Sign up here.