Assisted
Suicide Question Was Above Barack Obama’s Pay Grade in Previous Comments
by
Steven Ertelt
LifeNews.com Editor
September 3,
2008
Email
RSS
Printer
Washington,
DC (LifeNews.com) -- Weeks ago, pro-abortion presidential candidate
Barack Obama infamously said the question of when human life begins
is “above my pay grade” as a seeker of the White House. Judging
from Obama’s evasive answer on the question of assisted suicide,
it appears euthanasia was above his pay grade as well.
In
a March interview with the Mail Tribune, Obama wouldn’t give a clear
answer about whether he supports assisted suicide or Oregon’s first-in-the-nation
decision to legalize the grisly practice.
“I am in favor of palliative medicine in circumstances where someone
is terminally ill,” he said. “… I'm mindful of the legitimate interests
of states to prevent a slide from palliative treatments into euthanasia.”
At the same time, Obama appeared to praise Oregon for legalizing
assisted suicide without expressly saying he supports the decision.
“I think that the people of Oregon did a service for the country
in recognizing that as the population gets older we've got to think
about issues of end-of-life care,” he said.
Wesley
J. Smith, a noted attorney and author who is a bioethics watchdog,
pointed out what he says is an attempt on Obama’s part to get away
with not answering the question.
“It is a complete straddle, which is a disappointment given the
import of the issue,” Smith says. “Now, I note that there is an
ellipses at the end of the answer, which might have edited out a
more definitive response. But I doubt it, since a more definitive
response would be newsworthy.”
“This answer is along the lines of Obama's ‘above my pay grade’
punt about when human rights attach at the Saddleback Church,” Smith
said. “Such wiggling may be politically smart, but it is also not
leadership.”
Obama
came under significant
criticism in February when he said in a Democratic debate that
his biggest mistake was voting with a unanimous Senate to help save
Terri Schiavo.
Terri is the disabled Florida woman whose husband won the legal
right to starve her to death.
In
March 2005, just weeks before Terri died from a painful 14-day starvation
and dehydration death, Congress approved legislation allowing her
family to take its case
from state courts to federal courts in an effort to stop the euthanasia
from proceeding.
Terri was not on any artificial breathing apparatus and only required
a feeding tube to eat and drink. Her family had filed a lawsuit
against her former husband to allow them to care for her and give
her proper medical and rehabilitative care.
The Senate unanimously approved a compromise bill, which the House
eventually supported on a lopsided bipartisan vote and President
Bush signed, to help the disabled woman.
Obama said he should have stood up against the life-saving legislation.
“It wasn't something I was comfortable with, but it was not something
that I stood on the floor and stopped,” Obama said.
“And I think that was a mistake, and I think the American people
understood that that was a mistake. And as a constitutional law
professor, I knew better,” he added.
Obama
also addressed end-of-life
issues during the faith debate at Messiah College in April.
Obama was asked about patients who "wanted to take active steps
to end his or her own life."
Obama said society has to be "very careful in making end-of-life
decisions" and he promoted patients having a living will to
register their treatment choices.
The Illinois senator said he wanted to make sure patients can relieve
their own pain but said that opened up other questions.
"What happens then is you start getting into a gray area where
relieving pain and suffering may accelerate death in some situations
and that's a decision that should be made by the individual, the
family and the doctor," he said.
"I don't think that it's appropriate to empower doctors themselves
to make that decision," he added, appearing to oppose involuntary
euthanasia.
Yet, Obama, like Clinton, appeared noncommittal on the assisted
suicide question, and again repeated he wanted terminally ill patients
to be able to control their pain -- something the pro-life community
has never opposed.
Asked in a follow-up if that meant he would be open to patients
hastening the end of their lives, he said that has to be distinguished
from euthanasia.
"I think that there has to be very strict guidelines to ensure
that somebody who is making a decision to relieve their pain that
might take a week away from their life just because they are --
they are slipping into a coma quicker, for example," Obama
said.
"That that is distinguished from -- or at least there's a possibility
that they slip into a coma. That that's distinguished from euthanasia
in which someone else is making the decision for them," he
concluded.
Sign Up for Free Pro-Life News From LifeNews.com
|
Daily
Pro-Life News Report
|
Twice-Weekly
Pro-Life
News Report |
|
Receive
a free daily email report from LifeNews.com with the latest
pro-life news stories on abortion, euthanasia and stem cell
research. Sign
up here.
|
Receive
a free twice-weekly email report with the latest pro-life
news headlines on abortion, euthanasia and stem cell research.
Sign up here.
|





